While Wilmington’s downtown restaurants get plenty of well‑deserved attention, some of the city’s most beloved spots are off the beaten path. Beyond the Riverwalk crowds, you’ll find under-the-radar seafood, old-school buffets, classic diners and more tucked into neighborhoods all over town. If you want to eat like someone who actually lives here, start with these hometown favorites.

 

 

No-Frills Seafood

When you’re in the mood for fresh, homestyle seafood, these are three restaurants locals count on.

1. Something Fishy Restaurant

  • Pull up to this down‑home seafood shack for Calabash‑style plates piled high with fried trout, flounder, scallops and all the classic sides. Once featured on Food Network’s “Diners, Drive‑Ins and Dives,” Something Fishy keeps things simple with a “fish camp” feel, a straightforward menu and even a house‑made hushpuppy mix you can take home. Good to know: Something Fishy Restaurant is closed on Mondays.
  • Locals’ favorites: Hush Puppies, Fried Shrimp Platter, Fried Scallops Platter.

2. Seaview Crab Co. - Marstellar

  • Part seafood market, part restaurant, Seaview Crab Co. serves some of the freshest seafood in the city. Order dips, ceviche, soups, salads, tacos or sandwiches, or go for the made‑to‑order seafood that can be grilled or fried. Insider tip: After your meal, browse the market for spices, breading mixes and tools like oyster shuckers.
  • Locals’ favorites: Fried Okra, Steamed Blue Crabs, Lump Crab Cake Po’Boy.

3. Dockside Restaurant

  • A longtime Carolina tradition, Dockside Restaurant sits right on the Intracoastal Waterway near Wrightsville Beach. Expect a relaxed coastal atmosphere, plenty of boat traffic to watch and a menu that highlights local flavors. It’s also a popular filming location – and the place where Rx Chicken and Oysters’ Chef James Doss got his start.
  • Locals’ favorites: House-Made Chips, Peel & Eat Shrimp, Fish Tacos.

 

Casual Hangouts

This list of casual hangouts brings together the drive‑ins, buffets and neighborhood staples Wilmingtonians have visited for decades.

1. Casey’s Buffet

  • Help yourself to all‑you‑can‑eat Southern comfort food at this family‑owned buffet, known for barbecue, chitterlings, fried chicken and a long list of sides and desserts. Everything is house‑made and served hot, earning Casey’s a loyal local following – as well as a three-year streak on USA TODAY’s 10BEST Reader’s Choice Awards for Best Buffet Restaurant. Good to know: This spot is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays.
  • Locals’ favorites: BBQ Pork, Fried Chicken, Blueberry & Peach Cobbler.

2. Merritt's Burger House

  • Step back in time at this classic drive‑in, serving burgers, hot dogs, grilled cheese, fried chicken and fish plates since 1958. Pull into a numbered spot, place your order with a carhop and enjoy your meal right from the comfort of your car. Good to know: This restaurant is cash only and is closed on Sundays and Mondays.
  • Locals’ favorites: Double Cheeseburger, Hot Dog, BBQ Plate.

3. Winnie’s Tavern

  • Recommended by manna ave. 123 founder William Mellon, Winnie’s has been beloved since 1962 for its award‑winning burgers and friendly, laid‑back atmosphere. The famous Trailer Park Burger – topped with a fried green tomato, jalapeño‑pimento cheese and bacon – even made an appearance on The Cooking Channel’s “The Best Thing I Ever Ate.” Dine inside or grab a picnic table in the fenced‑in backyard. Insider tip: Read this recent feature in Our State magazine to learn more about the history of Winnie’s Tavern. 
  • Locals’ favorite: Trailer Park Burger, Blue Velvet Burger.

4. On Thyme

  • What began as a Black‑owned food truck is now a favorite brick‑and‑mortar spot in the Castle Street Arts District – and it comes highly recommended by Wilmington native and WilmingtoNColor founder Cedric Harrison. Visit the recently expanded space for tavern fare with a twist, including delicious sandwiches and creative takes on comfort food. Good to know: On Thyme is closed on Sundays and Mondays.
  • Locals’ favorites: Philly Cheesesteak Egg Rolls, Hot Chicken Sandwich, OMG Fish Sandwich.

5. J. Michael's Philly Deli

  • Calling all cheese lovers – J. Michael’s serves hoagies, grinders, soups and salads, plus steak and chicken‑steak sandwiches grilled with onions and special seasoning. Everything is piled high on hearth‑baked hoagie rolls and served hot!
  • Locals’ favorites: Philly Cheese Steak, Sweet Potato Fries (served with marshmallow icing).

 

Underrated Dinner Spots

Plan a coastal dinner at one of these three hidden gems across the city, from Historic Downtown Wilmington to the Brooklyn Arts District and beyond.

1. Three10 Wilmington

  • Tucked inside a restored historic home in the Brooklyn Arts District, Three10 offers sustainable, locally sourced coastal cuisine. Share a selection of small plates, then pair your entrée with a seasonal cocktail or a glass of organic wine. Good to know: Three10 is closed on Sundays and Mondays.
  • Locals’ favorites: Duck, NC Broiled Oysters, Seared Diver Scallop & Little Neck Clam "Chowder."

2. JohnnyLukes KitchenBar

  • This two‑story restaurant serves Southern comfort food, craft beers, eclectic wines and fun cocktails. Head downstairs for a relaxed lunch or dinner, or go upstairs to JL’s Loft for burgers and a cold beer. It’s a go‑to spot for groups looking for good food and chill vibes.
  • Locals’ favorites: Crab Dip, Meatball Sandwich, Uncle Stan's Chicken Pot Pie.

3. rumcow.

  • rumcow. offers American dishes with Asian‑inspired twists, plus a full bar featuring creative cocktails. Grab salads, shareables, burgers, sliders and seafood, along with inventive small plates like shrimp‑and‑grits tacos and pulled pork sushi rolls. Good to know: This spot is closed on Sundays. 
  • Locals’ favorites: Tuna Poke Tacos, Vietnamese Chicken Salad Lettuce Wraps, Wagyu Peppercorn Flank Steak.

 

Around the World in Wilmington

This list brings together global restaurants locals love, each offering a taste of the world without the need to travel.

1. Genki Japanese Restaurant

  • Settle in at this second‑generation, family‑owned Japanese restaurant, where dishes are prepared with filtered “Pi” water and house‑made sauces – including their own low‑sodium ponzu and soy sauce. Watch the sushi chef work from the bar and enjoy everything from udon and yakisoba to sashimi, vegetarian dishes and sushi. Don’t skip the house‑made caramel candies brought out with your receipt! Good to know: Genki Japanese Restaurant is closed on Mondays.
  • Locals’ favorites: Sushi, Age Dashi Tofu, Miso Soup.

2. A Taste of Italy

  • This family‑owned deli and specialty market brings classic New York Italian flavors to Wilmington. Enjoy generous portions of breakfast, lunch or dinner made from authentic family recipes, then browse the market for Italian staples to take home. Good to know: A Taste of Italy is closed on Sundays.
  • Locals’ favorites: Chicken or Eggplant Parmigiana.

3. Tandoori Bites

  • Choose from lamb, shrimp, fish, goat, chicken or vegetarian dishes at this restaurant, which Wilmington Magazine recognized as the city’s best Indian cuisine in 2025. Relax in the colorful dining room or covered outdoor patio while savoring bold, aromatic plates. Good to know: Tandoori Bites is closed on Tuesdays.
  • Locals’ favorites: Paneer Tikka, Lahori Fish Pakora, Tandoori Bites Kabob Trio.

4. Capricho

  • Named after the Spanish word for “craving,” this tiny downtown restaurant specializes in traditional Mexican street food: tacos, burritos, quesadillas and more, plus Mexican beer or soda. Be sure to check out the rotating daily specials. Good to know: Capricho is closed on Sundays and Mondays.
  • Locals’ favorites: Grouper Tostada, Camarones (Shrimp) Tacos, Churros.

Also check out:

 

Casual Breakfast and Brunch

Start your day at these six breakfast and brunch spots that have earned a loyal following.

1. Goody-Goody Omelet House

  • A Wilmington classic since 1977, Goody-Goody serves homemade Spanish omelets with signature sauce, steaming waffles, tangy chili and hand‑pattied burgers. The diner is small, often with a line out the door, but the friendly atmosphere and made‑from‑scratch dishes keep regulars coming back – including manna ave. 123 founder William Mellon. Good to know: This restaurant is cash only and is closed on Wednesdays.
  • Locals’ favorites: Omelets (try the Peaches & Cheese one), Pancakes, Hamburger.

2. Eternal Sunshine Cafe

  • Dig into delicious house-made breads and creative Benedicts at this locally owned café. Enjoy a mimosa flight inside by the colorful mural or outside on the patio.
  • Locals’ favorites: Any of the Benedicts, including The Great Crabsby (lump crab cake), Gordita Be Kidding Me (braised beef barbacoa) and Bean Me Up (black bean cake).

3. Jester's Cafe

  • Located in a charming bungalow (which was once a private residence) on Castle Street, Jester’s Cafe dishes up quiches, toasts and more. Dine inside or on the patio and enjoy brunch all day in a setting that feels like home. Good to know: This spot is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays. 
  • Locals’ favorites: Veggie or Meat Quiche, Avocado Toast (with homemade Castle Sauce), Classic Eggs Benedict.

4. Amanecer Cocina & Cafe

  • Start your day with inventive Mexican breakfast and brunch dishes, from chilaquiles and birria to omelets, pancakes and avocado toast. Pair your meal with fresh juices, mimosa flights or a spicy pineapple jalapeño margarita.
  • Locals’ favorites: Chilaquiles Tri-Color, Sunrise Burrito, Café de Olla (cinnamon coffee).

Also check out:

 

Worth the Hype

These eight restaurants draw plenty of visitors, but locals love them just as much. Whether you’re celebrating something special or simply want a standout meal, this list lives up to its reputation:

 

Bonus: Sips and Sweet Treats

Finish your day on a high note with a stop at one of these favorites for a coffee, cocktail or sweet treat.

 

Top